FIFA world player of the year awards were held last week. As expected, Kaka won the award getting 1047 votes. Lionel Messi and Christiano Ronaldo got 504 and 426 votes, coming second and third respectively. This has led to a hot debate in the footballing world about whether Kaka really deserves being the world player of the year. To help answer this question, lets have a brief look at each of these players achievements over the past year.
Although Kaka won the Champions League With AC Milan and was the top-scorer of the competition with 10 goals, his name was nowhere to be seen in the top scoring charts of Serie A and his side finished way off the pace. He also failed to win any domestic cups. He is an integral member of the Brazil national team but did not take part in their Copa America campaign (which Brazil won), claiming he was too 'tired' after a 'long and hard' season with AC milan. Coming to this season AC milan lie in an unbelievable 12th place in the Serie A table and have failed to register a win in their 7 home games. Surely, if Kaka is such a great player, he would have helped his team to attain much better results.
Lionel Messi is a great prospect for the future but I don't think he is the finished article yet last season, Barcelona went out in the early stages of the Champions league and did not win any of the domestic cups. They also failed to win the Spanish League, losing out to their bitter rivals Real Madrid on goal difference. Although Messi played well in many matches and scored some spectacular goals, he regularly went missing in big matches that really mattered and missed large parts of the season due to injuries. He failed in the Copa America with Argentina too, as Brazil defeated them comprehensively in the final. Giving him the second place ahead of Ronaldo is outrageous as he failed to win ANYTHING last season.
On the other hand, Christiano Ronaldo enjoyed a phenomenal season at Manchester United scoring an incredible 23 goals in all competitions as Manchester United had a real go at the treble. He played a great rolein the United's title-winning campaign last season and they came very close to winning the FA Cup too. He helped United to reach the Champions League semi-final as well. This season, Ronaldo has already scored 16 goals and is well on his way on surpassing his previous season's tally of goals. Moreover, he took his club form to the international stage helping Portugal to qualify for the Euro 2008 finals.
So it is clear that It was Ronaldo who deserved the FIFA world player of the year accolade ahead of Kaka ,who I think is hugely over-rated. I think Kaka got the award just because Milan defeated Manchester United in the semi-finals of the Champions League. In that tie, United played without many of their regular players, including their whole first-choice defensive like-up. On the other hand AC Milan had the luxury of all their star players for the European matches as they were out of all other competitions and had no chance of winning their league. I think FIFA its should review system of giving out the awards, because if awards continue to be dished out to wrong players, they will soon lose their importance and status.
Read more...